A story was broadcast on all major news channels a few weeks ago that the twenty-three year old woman, who was gang-raped on a bus in New Delhi, had died in hospital in Singapore. It was said that this was due to organ failure. We still do not know the name of this woman, but her attack has sparked huge protests all over India and attracted media attention all over the world. The story of this woman deserves all the attention from the media it can get. Sexual violence is a growing problem in India with the authorities doing very little to step in and put a stop to it.
But there was another story that cropped up in India that was not given the attention it needs. On 7th December, Nilofar Bibi, a twenty-two year old woman from Kolkata, was dragged into the streets and publicly beheaded by her brother. This heinous act was meant to restore the family’s honour after Bibi had left her alleged abusive in-laws and began living with a former boyfriend. The family have also expressed their support of this act as they say he upheld the honour of the family.
An honour killing is the murder of a family member or a member of the community, with the belief that the victim in some way has brought dishonour to that family or the community. These killings are related to parts of Africa and the whole of the Asian continent, however, they are very prevalent amongst the South Asian and Kurdish communities.
One of the situations we face at the moment, is that these crimes have now come across the waters and are in our own backyard. I have read many, many stories about honour killings but the majority of those stories are those that occur in the United Kingdom. Maybe this is because we are a small and developed country and it is very hard to hide a murder here. We do not have the type of villages as in developing countries and our authorities are less corrupt (we hope). It is very difficult to understand from a Western point of view why someone would commit murder when the victim did not exactly do anything wrong so the media will really focus on it.
An honour killing can occur for a list of reasons; defying parental authority, becoming “too western”, women having sex or relationships before marriage, alcohol or drug abuse, disagreements over dowries or even gossip from other members of the community. The victims of honour killings are mainly women. Looking at the list of reasons above, the males in the family can pretty much get away with all of these things because it is usually believed that the girls carry the honour in the family. A male is not killed because he dishonoured his own family but because he dishonoured the girl and her family and the murder would be carried out by the girl’s family, not his own. I am not saying that this does not happen, but I am yet to come across such an instance.
Bellow are listed the twenty-seven true stories of honour killings in the UK. Some of these stories vary in length due to lack of information. This can be due to bodies of the victims that have never been found, convictions of the killers being early in the discovery of honour killings, lack of witnesses, and/or non-guilty pleas of the defendants. I have chosen to only mention the names of the victims as I believe they should be the focus of this piece.
Tasleem Begum was married off to an older man in Pakistan at the tender age of sixteen. She was refusing to apply for a visa for her husband and it was then discovered that she had fallen in love with a married man. In June 1995, her brother-in-law knocked her down with his car and drove over her, reversed back over her and drove over her again. He was convicted of murder, but unfortunately was only given six and a half years at a retrial when he agreed to plead guilty.
Rukhsana Naz was only nineteen when she was murdered by her mother and twenty-two year old brother in March 1998. Naz was only fifteen when she was married off to a man in Pakistan and she had two children from this marriage. She had told her mother that she was pregnant with another man’s child and that she was going to divorce her husband. Naz’s mother had kicked her in the stomach and tried to make her daughter have an abortion, but she was already seven months pregnant. A week before the murder, Naz was forced to sign a will, which would give her mother guardianship of her two children in the event of her death. Whilst her mother held her legs, Naz’s brother strangled her with a piece of plastic flex. Once lifeless, her brother kissed his sister’s forehead and said, ‘I’m sorry’, then touched her stomach and said, ‘it’s not the kid’s fault, he’s innocent. Both are now serving life sentences.
It was discovered that Amjad Farooq was having an affair with his married niece. The girl’s husband and two other relatives kidnapped Farooq, dragged him into a field and hacked him to death in August 1998. It was also said that an attempt had been made to decapitate him. The girl’s husband and one of the relatives were both sentenced to life in prison whilst the other relative involved fled to Pakistan following the murder. He was arrested on his return in 2005 but was only charged with the kidnapping and served six years in prison.
Surjit Athwal was lured to India in December 1998 under the impression that she was to attend a wedding. This was set up by her mother-in-law and her husband as word had spread that Athwal was having an affair and planning to divorce her husband. Her murderers still roam free in India whilst the conspirators are serving their time in prison, the minimum of twenty years for Athwal’s mother-in-law and twenty-seven years for her husband. It is said that Athwal was strangled to death and then thrown into a river. Her body has never been found.
Tulay Goren, a Shia Kurdish Turk, was murdered by her father in January 1999 for having a Sunni boyfriend. It is believed that she was either smothered or strangled, but her body has never been found. Goren was only fifteen years of age. Her father was sentenced to a minimum of twenty-two years in prison. This honour killing encouraged police to travel to Turkey to learn and understand the “honour code” and what is considered as an “honour killing”.
Shahida Mohammed’s father returned home from Friday prayers one day in June 2001 to find his daughter in her bedroom with her boyfriend. Mohammed’s boyfriend jumped out of the window and her father then stabbed her with a knife nineteen times. The couple were full-clothed. Her father was sentenced to life in prison.
Nuziat Khan was trying to seek a divorce from her husband. It was claimed that he had been abusing her throughout their marriage. Her husband then strangled her to death in front of their three-year-old daughter in August 2001. It is believed that Khan’s husband had fled to Pakistan and still remains on Scotland Yard’s most wanted list.
Yasmin Akhtar was brought to the U.K. from Pakistan at the age of twenty-one to marry a man thirty years her senior. The marriage lasted for twelve years but she fled the home to a women’s refuge, claiming that she had been a victim of abuse for years at the hands of her in-laws. Akhtar filed for divorce, enraging her in-laws, but the marriage was dissolved and she was moved to a secret location. Akhtar then put in a claim of £250,000 from her ex-husband. Her step-son, from her ex-husband’s first marriage, decided that enough was enough. In March 2002, Akhtar’s ex-husband enlisted the help of three friends, kidnapped her from her home, and brought her to his shop. She refused to drop the claim and her ex-husband strangled her with parcel tape. The three friends were paid £10,000 to douse the body in petrol, wrap it in a carpet, take it to a near-by park and set it alight. All four are serving life in prison.
Nurjahan Khatun was only married to her husband for a year before he murdered her, Khatun’s four-year-old daughter, Fahmeda (from her first marriage) and brother, Kamal Udin, in September 2002. The marriage quickly became an unhappy one, with accusations from Khatun’s husband of fuelling her brother’s heroin addiction (not Udin), and of various affairs with women as well as men. They would also argue about her husband’s legal status in this country as he had entered the U.K. from Bangladesh illegally. It is believed that her husband had attacked Khatun’s daughter and brother first. There was a serious wound on his neck and it is believed that Khatun had tried to defend Fahmeda and Udin – he was mentally and physically disabled. Her husband used a dar, a sharp-bladed instrument used for cooking in Bangladesh, to hack to death his three victims. He is now serving three life sentences.
The case of Heshu Yones is arguably the case that put honour killings in the U.K. on the map. Yones was a sixteen-year-old Kurdish Iraqi and was stabbed to death by her father in October 2002 because she had an eighteen-year-old boyfriend who was a Lebanese Christian. Her father also feared she was becoming too “westernised”. Six months before her murder, her father had taken her to Iraqi Kurdistan and forced her to undergo a gynecological examination to prove that she was a virgin. Her father had beat her repeatedly over her relationship with her boyfriend and he had also found a secret stash of love letters. He stabbed her eleven times in the chest and slashed her throat. Her father then slashed his own throat and threw himself from a third-story balcony. He claimed that Al-Qaeda had broken into the flat and murdered his daughter. The police had found a letter in the flat from Yones to her father, telling him that he had a good punch for an old man. He is serving life in prison.
Rexhap Hasani was a twenty-two-year-old Roman Catholic, Albanian asylum-seeker, who had fallen in love with a Muslim girl. The girl’s father had tried to break up the relationship because he refused to accept the union. Hasani had promised to have an Islamic wedding and even changed his name to one that was Islamic but this was not enough. The girl’s father employed Hasani at his clothing factory and murdered him a week later in November 2002. Hasani had been bound, gagged and beaten before he was suffocated death. The girl’s father was sentenced to life in prison.
Sahjda Bibi was murdered by two of her cousins on her wedding day in January 2003. It is said that one of them was angered that Bibi had refused to marry one of his cousins and had chosen to marry a divorced man who was the father of a child from his previous marriage. The match was opposed by the family at first, but they grew to accept it. One of her cousins stabbed her repeatedly twenty-two times and the other drove the get-away car to the airport so he could catch a plane to Pakistan. Two months later, the knife-wielder was caught re-entering the U.K. on a flight from Dubai. Both are serving life sentences.
Shafilea Ahmed was murdered by her parents for being too “westernised” and rejecting an arranged marriage to her cousin in September 2003. On a trip to Pakistan, she rejected a proposal of marriage and then tried to drink bleach, which has now been seen as a suicide attempt. It is said that the rejection would bring dishonour to the family. Ahmed’s sister told the police that her father had put a plastic bag in her sister’s mouth and suffocated her. Her parents are now serving life sentences.
Sanjit Dosanjh, Temple Jazac and Malcolm Calver were all victims of an attempted honour killing. The plot was set up by Dosanjh’s father. Dosanjh, a Sikh woman, had fallen in love with a Jewish man she met on the internet, Temple Jazac. The pair had run off together but Sanjit’s father was furious that she was in a relationship with someone who was not of the same religion and culture. Her father had decided to hire a hitman in September 2003. The hitman he had approached was an undercover policeman. The pair had met a few times. The hitman was meant to shoot Malcolm Calver, the man Dosanjh’s father believed was Jazac’s father. Dosanjh and Jazac would then be coaxed out of hiding by coming to the funeral and then the couple would also be shot. Dosanjh’s father is now serving fourteen years in prison.
Major Singh Gill, a forty-five-year-old Sikh man, was beaten to death in August 2004 by six Muslim men. This was a case of mistaken identity. It was believed that Gill’s son was having a relationship with a Muslim girl. Gill was beaten with iron bars and hockey sticks. One man is serving eighteen years in prison, another is serving fifteen years. Another two men were found not guilty whilst two other men are believed to have fled to Pakistan.
Arash Ghorbani-Zarin was stabbed forty-six times by his girlfriend’s two brothers when they discovered their relationship and her pregnancy. Ghorbani-Zarin was of Iranian decent and his girlfriend and the family are Bangladeshi. The murder was ordered by the girl’s father in November 2004. The boys were only nineteen and sixteen. The girl’s father was sentenced to life in prison, the nineteen-year-old is serving sixteen years and the sixteen-year-old is serving fourteen years.
Samaira Nazir was a twenty-five-year-old business-women who was murdered by her father, brother and cousin in April 2005. Nazir had fallen in love with an Afghan asylum seeker and had rejected some suitors chosen by her parents. She was summoned to the family home where her mother, father, brother, two nieces and cousin were waiting for her. Nazir told her family that she wanted to marry her boyfriend, then her brother and cousin began their attack and she was stabbed eighteen times. Her cousin also slashed her throat three times. The family said she was not to marry someone outside their caste. A neighbour had heard the screams and went to the house but Nazir’s father shooed them away and said his daughter was having a fit. The police were called. When the police arrived, they found Nazir dead. They were also worried the two nieces, aged two and four, had watched the whole ordeal. Nazir’s brother is serving twenty years in prison and her cousin is serving ten years. Charges were dropped against her mother and her father fled to Pakistan whilst on bail. The family claim that he died there.
The sister-in-laws of Mohammad Shaheen had told their brother that Shaheen had sexually assaulted them. There were also rumours that he had been involved in a string of sexual offences over the course of a nine-year period. Their brother flew from Pakistan to the U.K. and shot Shaheen in the chest with a shotgun and killed him. After the murder, the sisters helped their brother escape to Pakistan. He was later found in Canada and extradited to the U.K. One of the sisters served a two-year prison sentence for perverting the course of justice. Shaheen’s brother-in-law is serving thirty years in prison before he can even be considered for release.
The story of Banaz Mahmod is probably one of the most famous honour killing cases in the U.K. to date, the reason being is that Mahmod went to the police on many occasions and told them that her father was going to kill her. The police dismissed her as a dramatic teenager. In 2003, when Banaz was seventeen, she was married off to a man who had recently arrived in the U.K. from Iraq. One of her sisters noticed a bruise on Mahmod’s arm and at first she dismissed the questioning. She then admitted she was being regularly beaten and raped by her husband. A family meeting was called but Mahmod was told to return to her husband and be a better wife. Mahmod returned to her parents’ home in September 2005 and reported her husband to the police – he was never prosecuted. She was too afraid to leave the house because she believed her husband was having people follow her and her suspicions were right. Mahmod began a relationship with another man. When it was discovered in December 2005, Mahmod’s father went to his brother and the plot to be rid of Mahmod began. Her uncle told Mahmod’s mother and her mother warned her daughter. The first attempt on her life was on New Year’s Eve when she was summoned to her grandmother’s house, and to bring a suitcase. Her father told Mahmod to drink alcohol and he was wearing surgical gloves. She was so frightened she ran out of the house and collapsed in the doorway of a nearby cafe. An ambulance was called and she was taken to hospital. The police came and she told them what happened…they did not believe her. An attempt to kidnap Mahmod’s boyfriend occurred not long after but his friends were there to protect him. It is said that Mahmod was raped before she was murdered in the living room of her family home in January 2006. Her uncle who had planned the murder was not in the house but was nearby to have removed the body and put it in a suitcase, the one which is believed to have been a part of the first murder attempt. When her boyfriend had not heard from her, he contacted the police and an inquiry began and they started making covert recordings. Mahmod’s father, uncle and a distant relative were arrested. The distant relative had an accident not long before the murder and was using a courtesy car, which was already fitted with a tracking device. Mahmod was found buried in a suitcase under a patio of a house. She was wearing nothing but a pair of knickers and had a shoelace around her neck. Because her body was found in April 2006, it was too decomposed to retain any more evidence. In the recordings, the distant relative had bragged about raping Mahmod before killing her, whilst her uncle unleashed the idea of the first plot to murder her. Mahmod’s father is now serving twenty years in prisons, her uncle is serving twenty-three years and the distant relative is only serving seventeen years because he pleaded guilty. Not giving up on the case, the police managed to have two other men involved in Mahmod’s murder extradited from Kurdish Iraq were they had fled. One is serving twenty-two years in prison and the other is serving twenty-one years.
Alisha Begum was only six-years-old when she was murdered. Her brother was in a relationship with a girl and the girl’s family found out. The girl’s two brothers and two other men carried out an arson attack on Begum’s family home in March 2006, with one of the men bursting through the door and pouring petrol in the hallway. A match was lit and the fire raged up the stairs. Many members of Begum’s family were forced to jump out of the upstairs windows as they were already in bed. Begum was the only one who did not escape. An eighteen-year-old involved is serving eight years in prison. He bought the petrol which was used for the attack. One of the girl’s brothers was acquitted one charge of murder and nine charges of attempted murder. The girl’s other brother and his friend fled to Bangladesh. The brother’s friend returned to the U.K. and was arrested and tried – he is now serving eleven years in prison whilst the fourth suspect is still at large and thought to still be in Bangladesh.
Uzma Rahan’s husband murdered her and their three children, Adam, eleven, Abbas, eight and Henna, six in July 2006. Rahan’s husband discovered that his wife was having an affair with their babysitter’s husband. Rahan also dressed too “western” and was ostracised from the community for being an adulterous. When Rahan flew to Pakistan to mourn her father’s death, her husband sold the house they owned together, flew to Pakistan and dumped the children with her, he filed fake divorce papers and went travelling on the proceeds from the sale of the house. The couple was encouraged to work on their marriage and bought another house back in the U.K. Rahan had told friends, ‘Count the days before he kills me’. Her husband beat his wife to death with a bat. It is thought that Abbas walked in and saw the murder. His father took him downstairs and then beat him to death. He then carried Henna out of her bed and did the same – and then the same for Adam. Before the murders, Rahan’s husband had booked himself a flight to Thailand; he cleaned off the bat and hid it in a shed, packed a bag and caught his flight. The bodies lay undiscovered for a month whilst Rahan’s husband travelled from Thailand to Malaysia. When trying to enter back into Thailand, Rahan’s husband was stopped at the border because he wanted in the U.K. and he was extradited. When taken off the plane by the police and read his rights, he said, ‘I confess to the murder’. He said he did not regret what he did to his wife but was upset about his children. In court, he tried to blame the murders of his children on Rahan, but he could not keep up with his own lies. Uzma Rahan’s husband is now serving four life sentences (one hundred years) in prison.
Caneze Riaz was born in the U.K. and had an arranged marriage with a very conservative man from Pakistan. Caneze was very confident, outgoing and well-respected in the community, her husband, however, could speak to English and worked low-paid jobs. The couple had five children together: one son, Adam, seventeen and four daughters, Sayrah, sixteen, Sophia, fifteen, Alicia, ten, and Hannah, three. Riaz and her children were very “westernised” which her husband did not like. It is thought that he felt a lot of pressure on him as his only son was ill in hospital with leukaemia and the final straw came when Sayrah stated she wished to become a fashion designer. When Riaz and the children were asleep, her husband had bolted all the doors, poured fuel all over the house and set the place on fire. Riaz and her four daughters all died in the blaze whilst her husband escaped and was taken to hospital has he was badly burned. The news was broken to Adam in hospital and was told that the main suspect was his father, Adam refused to see him. His father died two days after the murders of his wife and daughters. To make this story even more sad, Adam lost his fight against leukaemia six weeks after losing his mother and sisters.
Shawbo Ali Rauf was murdered by her husband and his family in May 2007 in Iraqi Kurdistan. She was from Birmingham and an unfamiliar number was found in her phone whilst on a picnic, which somehow proved she was having an affair. She was tortured and then shot seven times. Her gold was also found to be stolen. On returning to the U.K. many Kurdish women groups demanded Rauf’s husband be prosecuted…the police did nothing.
Yasmine and Sabrina Larbi-Cherif were murdered by Yasmine’s ex boyfriend in September 2008. Yasmine had gone to the police before to report her boyfriend’s violent behaviour towards her and was too scared to tell them her new address. We believe this is the reason the couple had split up. Her ex-boyfriend went to the flat belonging to the sisters and began to beat them. He then took a knife and stabbed them repeatedly. He was so forceful that the knife broke, he then took a second knife and started stabbing the girls again and that broke too. He reached for another knife and stabbed them to death. Yasmine’s ex-boyfriend is now serving thirty-four years in prison.
Laura Wilson’s story is the first story of its kind in the U.K.as Wilson was not Asian but English. Wilson had a child with an Asian man at the age of sixteen. This man was already married. However, Wilson was always in love with another Asian man and began a relationship with him, they were both seventeen. Wilson decided that she would go to the homes of both Asian men and confront their families. It is said when going to the family home of her baby’s father, his mother tried to hit her with a shoe. Both men found that she was dishonouring them and their families and she needed to be silenced. In October 2010, Wilson’s boyfriend had asked her to meet him down by a canal local to them. He stabbed her continuously with a knife and then threw her into the water. Wilson had multiple stab-wounds to the head, the police believe that her boyfriend continued to stab her when she was trying to climb out of the water. The father of Wilson’s child was acquitted whilst the other is serving seventeen years in prison.
* * *
At one point in my life, I had many Asian friends and there is a very good reason why this is no longer the case. Many Asians immigrated to the U.K. in the 60s and 70s in search of a better life. What seems to have happened is that although they sort of integrate, many traditions had values have stuck to them, and not the good kind. Many Asians that I have met in England have not come from the big cities in their home countries but have come from the villages where practically everything is ruled by a backward-mentality of what is considered “honour”. I have dated a Bangladeshi before and one of the reasons why our relationship terminated is because the family were not prepared to accept a girl who was not from the same country or culture, regardless of the fact that we were the same religion.
What confuses me the most about the family members that carry out these crimes is that they believe they are so justified in what they are doing, so why do they deny that they have committed murder when put in front of a judge? People do not hide what they believe is right. These people need to integrate into society more. Everyone has morals, but my father never beat me if I had a boyfriend. He would ask me a hell of a lot of questions and I feel sorry for the man who comes and asks him for my hand – the interrogation could last for hours! But my father has never told me that I was wrong for dating anyone or for the way I dress. Every man has pride, but why hurt people you love over something that does not matter? This type of “honour” is purely created by what others think of them and if that is the case, people need to mind their own business and worry about what goes on in their own lives rather than gossiping about everyone else.